S-23-0196: Case View

Case Heading (S-23-0196)
Case Number:	S-23-0196	Case Docketed On:	08/29/2023
Status:	Closed
Original Court:	Ninth Judicial District Teton County	Case Type:	Direct Appeal - Civil - Wyoming State Constitution
Short Title:	RACHEL RODRIGUEZ-WILLIAMS, House District Representative; CHIP NEIMAN, House District Representative; and RIGHT TO LIFE OF WYOMING, INC. v. DANIELLE JOHNSON; KATHLEEN DOW; GIOVANNINA ANTHONY, M.D.; RENE R. HINKLE, M.D.; CHELSEA'S FUND; and CIRCLE OF HOPE HEALTHCARE d/b/a Wellspring Health Access; STATE OF WYOMING; MARK GORDON, Governor of Wyoming; BRIDGET HILL, Attorney General for the State of Wyoming; MATTHEW CARR, Sheriff Teton County and MICHELLE WEBER, Chief of Police, Town of Jackson, Wyoming
Full Title:	RACHEL RODRIGUEZ-WILLIAMS, House District Representative; CHIP NEIMAN, House District Representative; and RIGHT TO LIFE OF WYOMING, INC., Appellants (Proposed Intervenors), v. DANIELLE JOHNSON; KATHLEEN DOW; GIOVANNINA ANTHONY, M.D.; RENE R. HINKLE, M.D.; CHELSEA'S FUND; and CIRCLE OF HOPE HEALTHCARE d/b/a Wellspring Health Access, Appellees (Plaintiffs), and STATE OF WYOMING; MARK GORDON, Governor of Wyoming; BRIDGET HILL, Attorney General for the State of Wyoming; MATTHEW CARR, Sheriff Teton County; MICHELLE WEBER, Chief of Police, Town of Jackson, Wyoming, Appellees (Defendants).

- Party Information

Role	Party Name	Attorney(s)
Appellant	Rachel Rodriguez-Williams	Frederick J. Harrison Denise Harle Timothy Garrison
Appellant	Chip Neiman	Frederick J. Harrison Denise Harle Timothy Garrison
Appellant	Right to Life of Wyoming, Inc.	Frederick J. Harrison Denise Harle Timothy Garrison
Appellee	Danielle Johnson	John H. Robinson Marci Anne Crank Bramlet Megan Cooney Peter Modlin
Appellee	Kathleen Dow	John H. Robinson Marci Anne Crank Bramlet Megan Cooney Peter Modlin
Appellee	Giovannina Anthony M.D.	John H. Robinson Marci Anne Crank Bramlet Megan Cooney Peter Modlin
Appellee	Rene R. Hinkle M.D.	John H. Robinson Marci Anne Crank Bramlet Megan Cooney Peter Modlin
Appellee	Chelsea's Fund	John H. Robinson Marci Anne Crank Bramlet Megan Cooney Peter Modlin
Appellee	Circle of Hope Healthcare	John H. Robinson Marci Anne Crank Bramlet Megan Cooney Peter Modlin
Appellee	The State of Wyoming	Jay Arthur Jerde
Appellee	Mark Gordon	Jay Arthur Jerde
Appellee	Bridget Hill	Jay Arthur Jerde
Appellee	Matthew Carr	Erin Elizabeth Weisman
Appellee	Michelle Weber	Lea Marie Colasuonno

- Case Decision Information
Issues:	Civil Procedure
Opinion Number:	2024 WY 16
Citation:

Docketing Filter View

Display:

Docket Information
Filing Date	Document Description	Docket Entry Type	Docket Entry Subtype	Status
08/29/2023	Event - Docketed and indexed	Event	Docketed and indexed	Final
08/29/2023	Notice-Incoming - Record completion notice from DC but no NOA received	Notice-Incoming	Record completion notice from DC but no NOA received	Final
08/29/2023	Fees - Docket fee received (Receipt e-served via CTEF)	Fees	Docket fee received	Final
08/29/2023	Notice-Outgoing - Docketing letter (E-Served via CTEF)	Notice-Outgoing	Docketing letter	Final
08/29/2023	Order - Sanction - notice of appeal	Order	Sanction - notice of appeal	Final
08/29/2023	Fees - Sanctions received - NOA	Fees	Sanctions received - NOA	Final
09/15/2023	Brief - Appellants	Brief	Appellant	Final
09/18/2023	Event - Hardcopy received - Brief of Appellants (Proposed Intervenors) Rachel Rodriguez-Williams, Chip Neiman, and Right to Life of Wyoming, Inc.; and received copy of appellants' designation of record on appeal	Event	Hardcopy received	Final
09/19/2023	Motion - Admission pro hac vice (Denise Harle)	Motion	Admission pro hac vice	Final
09/19/2023	Motion - Admission pro hac vice (Timothy Garrison)	Motion	Admission pro hac vice	Final
09/27/2023	Event - Hardcopy received - Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice (Denise Harle)	Event	Hardcopy received	Final
09/27/2023	Event - Hardcopy received - Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice (Timothy Garrison)	Event	Hardcopy received	Final
09/27/2023	Order Granting Admission of Attorneys Pro Hac Vice (Denise Harle and Timothy Garrison obo Appellant)	Order	Pro hac vice - allow	Final
10/20/2023	Notice-Incoming - other - Appellee Weber does not intend on filing a brief	Notice-Incoming	Status report - other	Final
10/27/2023	Brief - Appellees (State)	Brief	Appellee	Final
10/30/2023	Notice-Outgoing - Notice of case maturity	Notice-Outgoing	Notice of case maturity	Final
10/30/2023	Event - Hardcopy received - Brief of Appellees (State Defendants) and received Designation of Record	Event	Hardcopy received	Final
10/30/2023	Event - Hardcopy received - Notice of Not Filing a Brief from Appellee Michelle Weber, Chief of Police, Town of Jackson, Wyoming	Event	Hardcopy received	Final
10/30/2023	Failure to File - Brief of appellee (Matthew Carr)	Failure to File	Brief of appellee	Final
10/30/2023	Brief - Appellee (Johnson et al.)	Brief	Appellee	Final
10/30/2023	Motion - Judicial Notice (of documents from DC case #18732)	Motion	Other	Final
10/31/2023	Notice-Outgoing - Request for transmitted record on appeal	Notice-Outgoing	Request for transmitted record on appeal	Final
10/31/2023	Notice-Incoming - Amended index	Notice-Incoming	Amended index	Final
11/07/2023	Order - Oral argument scheduled	Order	Oral argument scheduled	Final
11/07/2023	Notice-Outgoing - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting (fill out and return to Clerk's Office)	Notice-Outgoing	Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting	Final
11/08/2023	Event - Hardcopies received - Brief of Appellees/Plaintiffs and Appellees'/Plaintiffs' Request for Judicial Notice	Event	Hardcopy received	Final
11/09/2023	Motion - Oral argument - vacate	Motion	Oral argument - vacate	Final
11/09/2023	Event - Vacating setting for oral argument	Order	Vacating setting for oral argument	Final
11/09/2023	Order - Oral argument scheduled	Order	Oral argument scheduled	Final
11/09/2023	Notice-Outgoing - Receipt acknowledgment - rescheduled oral argument setting (Complete and return to Clerk's Office)	Notice-Outgoing	Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting	Final
11/13/2023	Event - Hardcopy received - Unopposed Motion to vacate and Reschedule Oral Argument	Event	Hardcopy received	Final
11/13/2023	Motion - Admission pro hac vice (Peter S. Modlin and Megan Cooney obo appellees/plaintiffs)	Motion	Admission pro hac vice	Final
11/14/2023	Brief - Appellant reply	Brief	Appellant reply	Final
11/15/2023	Notice-Incoming - Record transmittal notice from district court	Notice-Incoming	Record transmittal notice from district court	Final
11/15/2023	Record - Transmitted record on appeal from the district court clerk, six volumes. Volumes 1-6, Original Papers.	Record	Transmitted record on appeal	Final
11/15/2023	Notice-Outgoing - Transmitted record on appeal filed	Notice-Outgoing	Transmitted record on appeal filed	Final
11/15/2023	Event - Hardcopy received - Reply Brief of Appellant's (Proposed Intervenors) Rachel Rodriguez-Williams, Chip Neiman, and Right to Life of Wyoming, Inc.	Event	Hardcopy received	Final
11/16/2023	Event - Hardcopy received - Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Co-Counsel for Appellees/Plaintiffs (Cooney and Modlin)	Event	Hardcopy received	Final
11/16/2023	Order - Pro hac vice - allow (Modlin and Cooney)	Order	Pro hac vice - allow	Final
11/17/2023	Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting from Jay Arthur Jerde obo State Appellees	Notice-Incoming	Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting	Final
11/21/2023	Order Granting Request for Judicial Notice	Order	Grant	Final
11/21/2023	Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting from Marci Crank Bramlet obo Plaintiffs/Appellees (appearing, but not arguing)	Notice-Incoming	Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting	Final
11/21/2023	Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting from Peter S. Modlin obo Plaintiffs/Appellees (arguing)	Notice-Incoming	Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting	Final
11/28/2023	Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting from Frederick J. Harrison obo Appellants (arguing)	Notice-Incoming	Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting	Final
12/12/2023	Notice-Internal - Oral argument notice argued before Chief Justice Fox; Justices Kautz; Boomgaarden; Gray and Fenn (Tim Garrison and Frederick Harrison appearing obo Appellants, with argument presented by Mr. Garrison; Jay Jerde arguing obo the Appellees/Defendants; and Peter Modlin and Marci Crank Bramlet appearing obo the Appellees/Plaintiffs, with argument presented by Mr. Modlin) and taken under advisement	Notice-Internal	Oral argument notice	Final
02/02/2024	Opinion - Opinion and journal order, affirming with Chief Justice Fox writing for the Court.	Opinion	Opinion and journal order	Final
02/21/2024	Record - Record returned to district court	Record	Record returned to district court	Final
02/21/2024	Notice-Outgoing - Mandate	Notice-Outgoing	Mandate	Final
02/21/2024	Notice-Outgoing - Record return letter	Notice-Outgoing	Record return letter	Final
02/21/2024	Event - Case closed	Event	Case closed	Final
03/11/2024	Service - Certified mail signature return card signed for 2/26/24	Service	Certified mail signature return card	Final